Opinions varied on federal lawsuit against Arizona's SB1070 - Tucson News Now

Opinions varied on federal lawsuit against Arizona's SB1070

By Barbara Grijalva - email

Tucson, AZ (KOLD) - We went to a South Tucson restaurant, a lunchtime focal point for people from all over Tucson, to find out what they think about the federal lawsuit against Arizona, and how it might change things in our state.

As you might imagine, opinions ran the gamut..

Whether people are for the lawsuit or against it, they want something to be done about immigration.

Some believe SB 1070 has been bad for business, and welcome the lawsuit as helpful.

"Not only for business, for the economy, for the city, for the state and for the county. I think this is good for everybody," says the restaurant's owner, Rigoberto Lopez, who is worried about his bottom line.

Others take SB 1070 more personally.

Tucsonan Judy Gonzalez says she and her husband are contemplating a move because of it.

"We both were born and raised in Arizona and we've considered leaving the state as a result of it," she says.

Gonzalez says overturning SB 1070 might change her mind.

Sunnyside Unified School Superintendent Manuel Isquierdo says, "I think it may encourage some of them to stay and maybe others to come back."

Cameron MacArthur was in town from Yuma.

He says, "I think this bill that was introduced was a knee jerk reaction to a serious problem, but not the right answer."

Then there are those who are for SB1070, who worry about being profiled under the law, but feel something needs to be done to stem the tide of illegal immigrants.@

Tucsonan Marisa Enriquez is one of them.

"If they want to come here, be in the United States then they should get their citizenship, instead of just coming here illegally," she says,

Others are more sure that SB 1070 is the right answer. 

"I think there needs to be some sort of standard, but because we don't have one that the federal government is enforcing, then the local government has to do what it thinks is in the best interests of its citizens," says Tucsonan Gabe Ruiz.

Tucsonan Julia Calderon says, "Now that this law is coming up, everybody is against us. Why? Why are they against us because we want to protect ourselves from all that's going on across the border?

One thing most agree on:  They hate the boycotts against Arizona.

Whether the federal lawsuit brings business back, is anybody's guess.

"No. I think there's deeper issues that people are waiting to see what's going to happen in the State of Arizona before they stop boycotting," says Carol Fimbres-Gaughan.

Businessman Rigoberto Lopez is hoping for a windfall because of the federal lawsuit to overturn SB 1070.

"Maybe in a few weeks, this is the comeback of the people and spend the money," he says.

SB 1070 is scheduled to take effect July 29th.

The judge in the lawsuit says she can't promise a ruling on a preliminary injunction to temporarily block enforcement of the law before that.

In the lawsuit, the federal government is asking for an injunction to keep the Arizona law from taking effect while the issue is in court.

A Tucson legal scholar says judges issue injunctions for several reasons.

One is that they look at who'll be harmed if the law is temporarily stopped, and who'll be harmed if it isn't.

The federal government argues that it will be harmed if the law goes into effect, while the state won't suffer a substantial burden.

University of Arizona law professor Marc Miller says, "It leaves the status quo and that, by the way, includes state law enforcement enforcing federal law under existing law that they can arrest somebody for violating federal law. They work with the federal government."

Miller says, "So, the question here is not whether or not Arizona can enforce federal immigration law at all.  It is only a question of the enforcement of these new crimes and new provisions" (in SB 1070).   

©2010 KOLD. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

  • Local newsMore>>

  • BREAKING

    Sabino Canyon may be without shuttle for months

    Sabino Canyon may be without shuttle for months

    Wednesday, June 20 2018 6:54 PM EDT2018-06-20 22:54:31 GMT
    Riders on Sabino Canyon tram. (Source: Tucson News Now)Riders on Sabino Canyon tram. (Source: Tucson News Now)
    Riders on Sabino Canyon tram. (Source: Tucson News Now)Riders on Sabino Canyon tram. (Source: Tucson News Now)

    Sabino Canyon may be without its shuttle system for months, according to the U.S. Forest Service.

    Sabino Canyon may be without its shuttle system for months, according to the U.S. Forest Service.

  • Pima Community College gets new baseball, softball coaches

    Pima Community College gets new baseball, softball coaches

    Wednesday, June 20 2018 5:23 PM EDT2018-06-20 21:23:18 GMT
    Pima Community College head baseball coach Rich Alday stepped down and Ken Jacome, one of Alday's former assistant at the University of New Mexico was chosen to be his successor. (Source: Pima Community College)Pima Community College head baseball coach Rich Alday stepped down and Ken Jacome, one of Alday's former assistant at the University of New Mexico was chosen to be his successor. (Source: Pima Community College)
    Pima Community College head baseball coach Rich Alday stepped down and Ken Jacome, one of Alday's former assistant at the University of New Mexico was chosen to be his successor. (Source: Pima Community College)Pima Community College head baseball coach Rich Alday stepped down and Ken Jacome, one of Alday's former assistant at the University of New Mexico was chosen to be his successor. (Source: Pima Community College)

    Pima Community College has new head coaches for its baseball and softball programs.

    Pima Community College has new head coaches for its baseball and softball programs.

  • Action Day: Dangerous heat expected on Friday

    Action Day: Dangerous heat expected on Friday

    Wednesday, June 20 2018 4:57 PM EDT2018-06-20 20:57:49 GMT

    The Tucson News Now First Alert weather team has called an Action Day for Friday, June 22, because of expected dangerous heat in southern Arizona.

    The Tucson News Now First Alert weather team has called an Action Day for Friday, June 22, because of expected dangerous heat in southern Arizona.

  • Trending StoriesTrending StoriesMore>>

  • 'Cut my hair': Officer and woman struggle during violent arrest

    'Cut my hair': Officer and woman struggle during violent arrest

    Tuesday, June 19 2018 10:59 PM EDT2018-06-20 02:59:31 GMT
    Tuesday, June 19 2018 11:12 PM EDT2018-06-20 03:12:26 GMT
    Alonso Luna struggled to tell another passenger to get the incident on video before she was forced out of the vehicle. (Source: CNN)Alonso Luna struggled to tell another passenger to get the incident on video before she was forced out of the vehicle. (Source: CNN)

    It involves a woman being dragged from the front seat of a car. And it involves an officer having her hair cut in order to break free of the suspect’s grip.

    It involves a woman being dragged from the front seat of a car. And it involves an officer having her hair cut in order to break free of the suspect’s grip.

  • Wrong newborn given to parents in WV

    Wrong newborn given to parents in WV

    Wednesday, June 20 2018 7:19 AM EDT2018-06-20 11:19:25 GMT
    Wednesday, June 20 2018 8:09 AM EDT2018-06-20 12:09:55 GMT

    Parents say a family spent valuable bonding time with the wrong newborn, including taking photos with him.

    Parents say a family spent valuable bonding time with the wrong newborn, including taking photos with him.

  • In reversal, Trump orders halt to his family separation rule

    In reversal, Trump orders halt to his family separation rule

    Wednesday, June 20 2018 11:21 AM EDT2018-06-20 15:21:21 GMT
    Wednesday, June 20 2018 6:57 PM EDT2018-06-20 22:57:58 GMT
    A boy stares out of a heavily tinted bus window leaving a U.S. Customs and Border Protection facility Tuesday in McAllen, TX. (AP Photo/Eric Gay)A boy stares out of a heavily tinted bus window leaving a U.S. Customs and Border Protection facility Tuesday in McAllen, TX. (AP Photo/Eric Gay)

    Trump signs executive order to keep families together at border, says 'zero-tolerance' prosecution policy will continue.

    Trump signs executive order to keep families together at border, says 'zero-tolerance' prosecution policy will continue.

Powered by Frankly