Justices grill feds in SB 1070 case - Tucson News Now

Justices grill feds in SB 1070 case

Protesters outside U.S. Supreme Court Protesters outside U.S. Supreme Court

"You can see it's not selling very well," said Supreme Court Associate Justice Sonya Sotomayor. "Why don't you try to come up with something else?"

Those two sentences summed up the federal government's day in front of the United States Supreme Court. Little went the way of Solicitor General David Donald Virrelli in his effort to assert supreme federal authority over immigration.

[SPECIAL SECTION: U.S. Supreme Court takes up Arizona's Immigration Enforcement Law]

The day began with all of the signs of a landmark day at the country's highest court. Hundreds of demonstrators showed up. Hundreds of observers stood in line for a ticket to see the showdown in person.

Eight justices heard the attorney for Arizona, Paul Clement, argue that SB 1070 simply requires police to do what the federal government already allows them to do - detain illegal immigrants.

Virrelli claimed immigration is the sole responsibility of the federal government.

Both men faced tough questions.

Justice Stephen Breyer hounded Clement about the law's requirement that police detain people they believe are illegal immigrants.

"It says any person who is arrested shall have the person's immigration status determined before the person is released. So I wonder if they have arrested a citizen, he's Hispanic looking, he was jogging, he has a backpack, he has water in it and Pedialyte, so they think, oh, maybe this is an illegal person," said Breyer. "Can you represent to us that he would not stay in detention for a significantly longer period of time than he would have stayed in the absence of section 2(b)?"

Clement responded, "I don't want to represent that."

But it was Virrelli who had the toughest sell.

Justice Antonin Scalia asked,"What's wrong about states enforcing federal law? There is a federal law about robbing banks."

Virrelli responded, "…here what we are talking about is….an area of dominant federal concern, exclusive federal concern."

Scalia asked, "Arizona has no power? What does sovereignty mean if it does not include the ability to defend your borders?"

"What we heard today in the Supreme Court was just awesome," announced former state Sen. Russell Pearce, who was the sponsor of the law.

Opponents tried to put a positive spin on the turn of events.

"I'm very optimistic that the justices will do the right thing and uphold the lower court's decision, but there are some serious questions there," said state Sen. Steve Gallardo, an outspoken critic of the law.

Gallardo conceded that it looked like the federal government missed some opportunities to make its point in the hearing.

The decision is expected by the end of June.

Copyright 2012 CBS 5 (Meredith Corporation). All rights reserved.

SIDEBAR: SB 1070

Updated:

SLIDESHOW: More>>

  • Local newsMore>>

  • BREAKING

    SAWMILL FIRE: Officials say at 61 percent contained

    SAWMILL FIRE: Officials say at 61 percent contained

    Saturday, April 29 2017 12:26 AM EDT2017-04-29 04:26:25 GMT

    Officials have confirmed the wildfire burning in southern Arizona was caused by a recreational shooter.

    Officials have confirmed the wildfire burning in southern Arizona was caused by a recreational shooter.

  • Economic Impact of Pima County Fair

    Economic Impact of Pima County Fair

    Saturday, April 29 2017 12:18 AM EDT2017-04-29 04:18:53 GMT
    (Source: Tucson News Now)(Source: Tucson News Now)

    The Southwestern Fair Commission says the event impacts our local economy by $34 million. They hired FMR Associates Inc to produce an Economic Impact study. 

    The Southwestern Fair Commission says the event impacts our local economy by $34 million. They hired FMR Associates Inc to produce an Economic Impact study. 

  • Firefighters saved more than homes from the Sawmill Fire

    Firefighters saved more than homes from the Sawmill Fire

    Saturday, April 29 2017 12:06 AM EDT2017-04-29 04:06:02 GMT
    (Source: Tucson News Now)(Source: Tucson News Now)

    The Sawmill Fire has burned nearly 47,000 acres, but thanks to the efforts of firefighting crews no homes have been lost.   

    The Sawmill Fire has burned nearly 47,000 acres, but thanks to the efforts of firefighting crews no homes have been lost.   

  • Trending StoriesTrending StoriesMore>>

  • Severe reaction to new sandals leads woman on a painful path

    Severe reaction to new sandals leads woman on a painful path

        One woman wants to warn people about her painful path, the result of a severe and debilitating allergic reaction.  She had no idea what she was allergic to until she visited a fourth emergency room in two weeks.    

    One woman wants to warn people about her painful path, the result of a severe and debilitating allergic reaction. She had no idea what she was allergic to until she visited a fourth emergency room in two weeks.    

  • 'The Phantom' serial killer of children out of prison, living in Tucson

    'The Phantom' serial killer of children out of prison, living in Tucson

    Thursday, April 27 2017 12:17 AM EDT2017-04-27 04:17:43 GMT
    Friday, April 28 2017 11:32 PM EDT2017-04-29 03:32:02 GMT
    Convicted killer William Huff was spotted riding his bicycle through a Tucson neighborhood. (Source: 3TV/CBS 5)Convicted killer William Huff was spotted riding his bicycle through a Tucson neighborhood. (Source: 3TV/CBS 5)

    William Huff terrorized Sierra Vista during the spring and summer of 1967. Despite a sentence of 40 years to life, the Arizona Board of Executive Clemency voted to release him from prison into home arrest. Family members of the victims are concerned for the safety of the community, as are new members of the Clemency Board. CBS 5 Investigates videotaped Huff riding a bike through his Tucson neighborhood. There are no restrictions placed on his proximity to children.

    William Huff terrorized Sierra Vista during the spring and summer of 1967. Despite a sentence of 40 years to life, the Arizona Board of Executive Clemency voted to release him from prison into home arrest. Family members of the victims are concerned for the safety of the community, as are new members of the Clemency Board. CBS 5 Investigates videotaped Huff riding a bike through his Tucson neighborhood. There are no restrictions placed on his proximity to children. 

Powered by Frankly