Officer who arrested man in 1970 Pioneer fire speaks out - Tucson News Now

Officer who arrested man in 1970 Pioneer fire speaks out

David Smith David Smith
TUCSON, AZ (Tucson News Now) -

A man who has spent more than four decades in prison for a Tucson hotel fire that killed 29 people, including some who jumped from windows to escape the searing heat, is expected to be released Tuesday as part of a deal with prosecutors.

Louis Taylor was convicted as a teen and has maintained his innocence in the December 1970 fire at the Pioneer Hotel.

The Tucson police detective who arrested Taylor the day after the blaze is David Smith, who is  now a fire instructor who runs a consulting firm in Bisbee. 

"At one point he yelled at me 'I didn't want to kill those people.'  Since then, you know, I've discussed this numerous times and people have said couldn't he have meant this or could he have meant that," says Smith. 

He says Taylor made some suspicious statements at the time, which led to his arrest.  Taylor apparently suggested others started the deadly fire.

"I said who did and he says it was as black kid and two Mexican kids, and I said how do you know they did it?  And he said because they looked me in the eye and I saw that they did it."

Smith admits arson investigations have changed since the Pioneer fire.  He says there is more science involved.

"If you saw window glass that was crazed meaning tiny spider webs, that meant it was a very hot and fast fire.  Wait a minute, crazed glass is caused by rapid cooling not rapid heat," says Smith.

Smith now works with a group called the Innocence Project which helps clear the names of the wrongly convicted.  Years ago Innocence Project asked him to review a 1992 Texas arson case.  Smith used his skills in arson investigation to prove the man who was executed did not start the fire in that case.

"I can't fathom being in prison let alone being in prison for something that I didn't do."

All things considered, Smith says he has an open mind when it comes to innocence and guilt.  He says it's possible Taylor did not start the fire back in 1970.

"I'm certainly not going to sit here and say don't confuse me with facts, I know what happened, because that's certainly not the case."

Copyright 2013 Tucson News Now.  All rights reserved.

  • Local newsMore>>

  • Border Patrol agents arrest 57 undocumented immigrants

    Border Patrol agents arrest 57 undocumented immigrants

    Saturday, June 23 2018 1:30 AM EDT2018-06-23 05:30:32 GMT
    (Source: Border Patrol Tucson)(Source: Border Patrol Tucson)
    (Source: Border Patrol Tucson)(Source: Border Patrol Tucson)
    Tucson Sector Border Patrol agents assigned to the Ajo Station arrested a large group of aliens during a heat wave, some in distress, including a pregnant female, west of Lukeville Friday afternoon.  Agents were alerted to the group’s location after receiving a call from the Sonora, Mexico’s 9-1-1 center relaying information from persons within the group. The callers, stated they had crossed the border illegally, and requested assistance.   Ajo Station age...
    Tucson Sector Border Patrol agents assigned to the Ajo Station arrested a large group of aliens during a heat wave, some in distress, including a pregnant female, west of Lukeville Friday afternoon.  Agents were alerted to the group’s location after receiving a call from the Sonora, Mexico’s 9-1-1 center relaying information from persons within the group. The callers, stated they had crossed the border illegally, and requested assistance.   Ajo Station age...
  • Firework sales begin, can be lit starting Sunday

    Firework sales begin, can be lit starting Sunday

    Friday, June 22 2018 11:40 PM EDT2018-06-23 03:40:36 GMT

    The Fourth of July is creeping up quick, and that means several vendors like Desert Sky Fireworks on Cortaro and I-10 are getting ready for the season. The location set up shop on Friday.  "Lining them all up on the road -- lighting them all up and competing with the neighbors," said Ashley Walling, who runs the shop. Fireworks sparked her interest at an early age.   She started selling them when she was sixteen in ...

    The Fourth of July is creeping up quick, and that means several vendors like Desert Sky Fireworks on Cortaro and I-10 are getting ready for the season. The location set up shop on Friday. "Lining them all up on the road -- lighting them all up and competing with the neighbors," said Ashley Walling.

  • Volunteers clean graffiti out of Peppersauce Cave this weekend

    Volunteers clean graffiti out of Peppersauce Cave this weekend

    Friday, June 22 2018 9:53 PM EDT2018-06-23 01:53:32 GMT

    A popular spot for outdoor recreation has become overrun with graffiti once again. Dozens of volunteers will continue efforts to clean more than 1,500 graffiti tags around Peppersauce Cave this weekend. Central Arizona Grotto, a caving club out of Phoenix, has organized people from all over the state to help remove roughly 800 tags. Previous clean up trips by the group have already lifted approximately 750 tags, according to organizer Ray ...

    A popular spot for outdoor recreation has become overrun with graffiti once again. Dozens of volunteers will continue efforts to clean more than 1,500 graffiti tags around Peppersauce Cave this weekend. Central Arizona Grotto, a caving club out of Phoenix, has organized people from all over the state to he

Powered by Frankly