Local legislation on art causes controversy - Tucson News Now

Local legislation on art causes controversy

TUCSON, AZ (Tucson News Now) - It may not fit your definition of art, but a new sculpture to go with the improved Grant and Oracle intersection fits under Tucson and Pima County legislation, which requires one percent of a roadway project's budget to be dedicated to public art.

We've gotten a lot of comments on our Facebook page about the $90,000 project since we first reported about it Monday.  The piece by public artists Hank Saxe and Cynthia Patterson reflects elegant desert plants and offers a tribute to the Pascua Yaqui people.  The sculpture is also supposed to be reminiscent of some of the first boundary markers between the U.S. And Mexico in the 1850's. 

But it's the price tag commenters find less than beautiful.  Several call it a waste of money, saying that money should be put into street repairs, not street art. 

The Regional Transportation Authority says the artwork is part of a master plan [PDF], which included input from both local artists and the public back in 2010, which involved the Tucson-Pima Arts Council.  Tucson is also not alone in requiring one percent of construction projects to go towards public art.  According to the National Assembly Of State Arts Agencies, similar programs are active in 25 states, which include both physical and performing arts.  The one-percent concept for public art funding dates back to at least 1959, when Philadelphia became the first city in the United States to make an art-funding requirement as part of the development process.

It hasn't come without controversy.  In Tucson alone, the giant red sculpture outside the main library downtown has attracted consistant criticism over the years.  A few weeks ago, a Tempe artist unveiled nude sculptures outside an apartment complex on Ft. Lowell Road.  No public money was used for the statues, which are on private property, and the Tempe artist did not seek approval from Tucson's design review board.

As for the artwork on Grant Road, more pieces will be installed as it's widened.

Copyright 2013 Tucson News Now. All rights reserved.

  • Local newsMore>>

  • Police: Tucson man assaulted and kidnapped; still missing

    Police: Tucson man assaulted and kidnapped; still missing

    Friday, April 27 2018 12:46 AM EDT2018-04-27 04:46:15 GMT
    Timothy Abriola (Source: Tucson Police Department)Timothy Abriola (Source: Tucson Police Department)

    Police say an AutoZone on 13th Avenue and Irvington Road was the site of a troubling crime early Thursday morning. 

    Police say an AutoZone on 13th Avenue and Irvington Road was the site of a troubling crime early Thursday morning. 

  • ONLY ON KOLD: The worst road in Pima County and why you may be paying for it

    ONLY ON KOLD: The worst road in Pima County and why you may be paying for it

    Thursday, April 26 2018 10:45 PM EDT2018-04-27 02:45:47 GMT
    The five-mile stretch of Ruby Road near Arivaca was once called "the worst maintained" road in Pima County. The county has spent a lot of money to try to fix it. (Source: Tucson News Now)The five-mile stretch of Ruby Road near Arivaca was once called "the worst maintained" road in Pima County. The county has spent a lot of money to try to fix it. (Source: Tucson News Now)
    The five-mile stretch of Ruby Road near Arivaca was once called "the worst maintained" road in Pima County. The county has spent a lot of money to try to fix it. (Source: Tucson News Now)The five-mile stretch of Ruby Road near Arivaca was once called "the worst maintained" road in Pima County. The county has spent a lot of money to try to fix it. (Source: Tucson News Now)

    A five-mile stretch of Ruby Road near Arivaca was once called "the worst maintained" road in Pima County. The county has spent plenty to try to fix it but thinks someone else should be on the hook the next time.

    A five-mile stretch of Ruby Road near Arivaca was once called "the worst maintained" road in Pima County. The county has spent plenty to try to fix it but thinks someone else should be on the hook the next time.

  • Teachers say walk out will continue as long as needed

    Teachers say walk out will continue as long as needed

    Thursday, April 26 2018 11:18 PM EDT2018-04-27 03:18:21 GMT

    More than a thousand teachers, supporters and staff lined Broadway at Congress and Granada amid a sea honking horns, cheers and waves as the cars passed by showing their support. The teachers promised to paint the street red and they didn't disappoint. 

    More than a thousand teachers, supporters and staff lined Broadway at Congress and Granada amid a sea honking horns, cheers and waves as the cars passed by showing their support. The teachers promised to paint the street red and they didn't disappoint. 

  • Trending StoriesTrending StoriesMore>>

  • 'Extreme pain': Teen found stabbed, burned alive

    'Extreme pain': Teen found stabbed, burned alive

    Thursday, April 26 2018 9:24 AM EDT2018-04-26 13:24:51 GMT
    Thursday, April 26 2018 11:09 AM EDT2018-04-26 15:09:23 GMT
    Police said a 911 caller thought he saw the body of Tyrell Holmes crawling on the ground while still on fire. Holmes died from smoke inhalation, thermal injuries and stab wounds. (Source: WFMX/CNN)Police said a 911 caller thought he saw the body of Tyrell Holmes crawling on the ground while still on fire. Holmes died from smoke inhalation, thermal injuries and stab wounds. (Source: WFMX/CNN)

    Police said a 911 caller thought he saw the body of Tyrell Holmes crawling on the ground while still on fire. Holmes died from smoke inhalation, thermal injuries and stab wounds.

    Police said a 911 caller thought he saw the body of Tyrell Holmes crawling on the ground while still on fire. Holmes died from smoke inhalation, thermal injuries and stab wounds.

  • Exclusive: Interview with woman who adopted OJ and Dozer

    Exclusive: Interview with woman who adopted OJ and Dozer

    Thursday, April 26 2018 6:19 PM EDT2018-04-26 22:19:09 GMT
    OJ and Dozer go for a walk Thursday after they were reunited the night before (Source: RACC)OJ and Dozer go for a walk Thursday after they were reunited the night before (Source: RACC)

    The woman who adopted OJ and Blue Dozer from Richmond Animal Care and Control is speaking for the first time after the two dogs were reunited Wednesday night. 

    The woman who adopted OJ and Blue Dozer from Richmond Animal Care and Control is speaking for the first time after the two dogs were reunited Wednesday night. 

Powered by Frankly